9 PDF to EPUB converters: a real-paper comparison
Compare nine converters using the same published research-paper excerpt. Download the untouched competitor results, including FreeConvert and Online-Convert, and inspect column order and figures alongside EPUBTurn’s manually reviewed result. This is one document test, not a general accuracy ranking.
On this page
- The real paper used for this comparison
- How the EPUBTurn result was made
- Nine converters, three named reading checks
- What EPUBTurn retained—and what was clipped
- Calibre
- Convertio
- PDF24 Flow
- pdf2ereader
- CloudConvert: October 7 rerun
- Zamzar: October 7 rerun
- FreeConvert: same-paper conversion
- Online-Convert: same-paper conversion
- Choose a permitted workflow, then judge its content
- The source, raw files and your next check
- Choose a guide for your document
- Reuse the observations or repeat the test
The real paper used for this comparison
Nine routes can produce very different reading files from the same research PDF. We compared a real ten-page Nature Communications excerpt with dense columns, a multi-panel figure and numerical results. Eight default competitor downloads are available. CloudConvert and Zamzar became available on the October 7 retry after the earlier free-access limits. EPUBTurn produced a reviewed result after manual equation corrections.
We publish EPUBTurn. The comparison uses the source and saved results so you can inspect the evidence.
How the EPUBTurn result was made
EPUBTurn’s initial automatic workflow stopped on page 7. Three equation image boundaries were manually corrected before a reviewed result was made. Competitor files use their stated defaults. The remaining figure defect was not repaired.
Nine converters, three named reading checks
The nine are EPUBTurn, Calibre, CloudConvert, Convertio, PDF24 Flow, Zamzar, pdf2ereader, FreeConvert and Online-Convert. We check column order, Figure 1’s panels and caption, and exact values with their population conditions. Eight untouched competitor outputs are available. CloudConvert and Zamzar were retried on October 7; FreeConvert and Online-Convert were also tested on October 7. The other files are from October 6. EPUBTurn’s reviewed result retained the passage order and numeric associations, with a partial Figure 1 crop.
| Provider | Column order | Figure 1 panels/caption | Values with population conditions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calibre | Issue: interleaved | Issue: panels absent | Partial: disrupted association |
| Convertio | Issue: interleaved | Issue: panels absent | Partial: disrupted association |
| PDF24 Flow | Issue: interleaved | Issue: panels absent | Partial: disrupted association |
| pdf2ereader | Issue: interleaved | Issue: panels absent | Partial: disrupted association |
| EPUBTurnOur converter | Retained: ordered passages | Partial: lower axes clipped | Retained: values with conditions |
| CloudConvert | Issue: interleaved | Issue: panels absent | Partial: disrupted association |
| Zamzar | Issue: interleaved | Issue: panels absent | Partial: disrupted association |
| FreeConvert | Issue: interleaved | Issue: panels absent | Partial: disrupted association |
| Online-Convert | Issue: interleaved | Issue: panels absent | Partial: disrupted association |
What EPUBTurn retained—and what was clipped
EPUBTurn’s reviewed file kept the left passage before the right continuation and preserved the inspected Results values with their population conditions. Figure 1 retained the map, density curve and scatterplot with the caption. Its crop nevertheless cut off lower x-axis ticks and titles in panels B and C. Count that figure as partial and keep the PDF for those labels.
Published source PDF

EPUBTurn reviewed result

Published source PDF

EPUBTurn reviewed result

Calibre
Calibre’s default output placed the right-column interval inside the left opening and omitted Figure 1’s visual panels. Numeric text remained, but the interleaving disrupted its context. Compare the untouched output with EPUBTurn’s reviewed result; the different review conditions remain part of this comparison.
Calibre

EPUBTurn reviewed result

Calibre

EPUBTurn reviewed result

Convertio
Convertio’s default output placed the right-column interval inside the left opening and omitted Figure 1’s visual panels. Numeric text remained, but the interleaving disrupted its context. Compare the untouched output with EPUBTurn’s reviewed result; the different review conditions remain part of this comparison.
Convertio

EPUBTurn reviewed result

Convertio

EPUBTurn reviewed result

PDF24 Flow
PDF24 Flow’s default output placed the right-column interval inside the left opening and omitted Figure 1’s visual panels. Numeric text remained, but the interleaving disrupted its context. Compare the untouched output with EPUBTurn’s reviewed result; the different review conditions remain part of this comparison.
PDF24 Flow

EPUBTurn reviewed result

PDF24 Flow

EPUBTurn reviewed result

pdf2ereader
pdf2ereader’s default output placed the right-column interval inside the left opening and omitted Figure 1’s visual panels. Numeric text remained, but the interleaving disrupted its context. Compare the untouched output with EPUBTurn’s reviewed result; the different review conditions remain part of this comparison.
pdf2ereader

EPUBTurn reviewed result

pdf2ereader

EPUBTurn reviewed result

CloudConvert: October 7 rerun
The default CloudConvert EPUB is available to download unchanged. At the checked column transition it places a right-column interval inside the left passage. Figure 1 has text but no map or plot panels. These observations describe this file and these settings, not every document the service can convert.
CloudConvert

EPUBTurn — reviewed result

CloudConvert

EPUBTurn — reviewed result

Zamzar: October 7 rerun
The default Zamzar EPUB is available to download unchanged. At the checked column transition it places a right-column interval inside the left passage. Figure 1 has text but no map or plot panels. These observations describe this file and these settings, not every document the service can convert.
Zamzar

EPUBTurn — reviewed result

Zamzar

EPUBTurn — reviewed result

FreeConvert: same-paper conversion
We uploaded the same ten-page research PDF to FreeConvert on October 7 and kept the web form defaults. The untouched EPUB places the right-column interval “16.82–18.96; n = 57 sites” alongside the left passage beginning “some species, numerous, young, mature, female fish”. Reading across those lines mixes two separate passages. Figure 1’s caption remains, but its map and plot panels are absent; the EPUB contains only two small branding images.
For this paper, EPUBTurn’s reviewed copy is easier to follow at the checked column transition. EPUBTurn required three manual equation corrections, and lower figure axes remain clipped. The side-by-side views compare that reviewed file with FreeConvert’s unchanged download, using original EPUB styles at 1280 × 900. Different review conditions matter; we have not tested speed or a physical reader.
FreeConvert

EPUBTurn — manually reviewed

Online-Convert: same-paper conversion
We uploaded the same ten-page research PDF to Online-Convert on October 7 and kept the web form defaults. The untouched EPUB places the right-column interval “16.82–18.96; n = 57 sites” alongside the left passage beginning “some species, numerous, young, mature, female fish”. Reading across those lines mixes two separate passages. Figure 1’s caption remains, but its map and plot panels are absent; the EPUB contains only two small branding images.
For this paper, EPUBTurn’s reviewed copy is easier to follow at the checked column transition. EPUBTurn required three manual equation corrections, and lower figure axes remain clipped. The side-by-side views compare that reviewed file with Online-Convert’s unchanged download, using original EPUB styles at 1280 × 900. Different review conditions matter; we have not tested speed or a physical reader.
Online-Convert

EPUBTurn — manually reviewed

Choose a permitted workflow, then judge its content
Local control, upload permission and access conditions can decide a workflow before content quality. Those practical factors remain separate from the three inspected reading tasks.
Browser captures use a 1280 × 900 view at 100% zoom. No native reader or device was tested. This paper has no scan or table-grid test; no accuracy or speed ranking is claimed.
The source, raw files and your next check
Source: Hadj-Hammou et al. (2024), Global patterns and drivers of fish reproductive potential on coral reefs, Nature Communications 15:6105, doi:10.1038/s41467-024-50367-0. CC BY 4.0. We used original pages 1–10, omitting the final reference/licence page. No source wording was rewritten. Converted files and screenshot excerpts are adaptations.
Choose a passage that reveals your actual problem: a column transition, a useful chart or an exact result with its condition. Try an EPUBTurn sample and compare the included pages with the source. Up to ten automatic pages may omit the feature you need; an omitted feature remains unchecked.
Choose a guide for your document
For your own file, follow the research-paper conversion steps or the textbook-chapter workflow. The image checks explain why keeping a picture is different from keeping every label.
Reuse the observations or repeat the test
The downloadable CSV includes the source and output links, file hashes, observed checks and manual-intervention notes. EPUBTurn’s reviewed result and competitors’ untouched results are different workflows: the dataset records that distinction. Correction time was not measured. You can reuse our observation data under CC BY 4.0; the method notes explain attribution and the separate rights for source documents.
Files used in this guide
Download the source files, conversion results or worksheets referenced here. Each label identifies the source document or the converter used.
Published source excerpt, pages 1–10EPUBTurn reviewed published-paper EPUBCalibre untouched published-paper EPUBConvertio untouched published-paper EPUBPDF24 Flow untouched published-paper EPUBpdf2ereader untouched published-paper EPUBDownload comparison observations (CSV)Comparison method and reuse notes (text)CloudConvert — untouched October 7 research-paper EPUBZamzar — untouched October 7 research-paper EPUBFreeConvert — untouched October 7 EPUBOnline-Convert — untouched October 7 EPUBRelated guides
- EPUBTurn and CloudConvert: compare a real research PDF
- Build a reproducible PDF to EPUB comparison record
- EPUBTurn and PDF24 Flow: compare a real research PDF
- EPUBTurn and Convertio: compare a real research PDF
- EPUBTurn and Zamzar: compare a real research PDF
- EPUBTurn vs PDF2EPUB: compare a published research paper
- EPUBTurn vs pdftoepub.app: check a complex paper before choosing
- EPUBTurn vs pdftoepub.org: compare the selected conversion mode
- EPUBTurn and pdf2ereader: compare a real research PDF
- ABBYY or EPUBTurn for research PDFs: choose the reading workflow
- Cisdem or EPUBTurn: compare the workflow for illustrated papers